The Best Mystery Boxes

We all love a good mystery. Many of us can't resist the "what's in the box" feeling anytime we get a package in the mail. Imagine if you could make every delivery a true surprise? You can with mystery boxes. These fun boxes are specially curated to bring you joy and fun without the pressure you would usually feel to pick just the right thing. Here are our favorite mystery boxes.

What to Look For

When it comes to mystery boxes, the sky’s the limit. Look for boxes that come with a variety of different items, from snacks to makeup and beyond. Make sure you select one with an intriguing mix — you never know what surprises lurk inside. Also, look for boxes that are full of high-quality products that offer good value for money. Ultimately, choose a mystery box that meets your needs and offers great value. For example, if you’re a fan of long, relaxing baths, LifeAround2Angels gift box offers a dozen bath bombs designed to moisturize the skin and soothe the senses. And for collegebound kids, consider CraveBox’s care package, which features a generous selection of sweet and salty favorites. Read on to uncover more about our favorite mystery boxes. There’s something for everyone.

LifeAround2Angels Bath Bombs Gift Set

A relaxing surprise

The only thing better than a bath bomb is 12 bath bombs, which is what you get with this variety pack.
Top Pick

Find on Amazon

Scoring the top spot on our list, this option from LifeAround2Angels helps you give the gift of bathtime. Each of the twelve bath bombs in this chic gift box is totally unique. Some feature subtle glitters, while others are adorned with flower petals. And although they differ in appearance, each bath bomb in the set is comprised of the same moisturizing ingredients, such as organic coconut oil and shea butter. With LifeAround2Angles Bath Bombs, we won’t fault you for buying an extra box for yourself.

Pros:

  • The smell is rich and relaxing
  • Effectively moisturizes the skin
  • The scent, glitter, and flower petals are subtle and not overpowering
  • They immediately fizz and dissolve in the tub

Cons:

  • Some color may remain behind after you drain the tub, but this can be cleaned off with a detachable showerhead or just a clean rag

FantasyDay Pro Makeup Gift Set

A glamorous gift

This beautiful box is a welcome surprise for the makeup connoisseur.
Best Beauty Box

Find on Amazon

If you or someone special is a makeup aficionado, we recommend the FantasyDay Pro Makeup Gift Set. Each mystery box is comprised of a unique assortment of products from FantasyDay. Which specific products you’ll receive truly is a mystery, though every box is packed with plenty of useful and quality makeup items. Not only are there many makeup products in each box, but there are also add-ons like makeup brushes, compacts, lash curlers, and more. Order yours today and find out what all the fuss is about.

Pros:

  • This mystery box offers an affordable way to stock up on a massive quantity of makeup products
  • A great gift for beginners that are still experimenting with different types of makeup
  • Each box is unique

Cons:

  • You don’t get to choose which specific products you’ll get, so it’s a bit of a gamble

CraveBox Care Package

A snacker's delight

This is an ideal gift for college students or anyone that likes their comfort foods.
Best Snack Box

Find on Amazon

Sending someone a CraveBox is a great way to let them know you care. Chock-full of all the best snacking essentials, this option satisfies cravings for the sweet and the salty. We like sending these care packages to our friends and family members that are in college and overseas. After all, nothing helps you cram for a final exam quite like a little fruit snack pick-me-up.

Pros:

  • The variety makes sure that there are snacks that the recipient will enjoy
  • The snacks are individually wrapped, so they can be enjoyed over several weeks
  • With so many snack items, this option is a modestly-priced care package

Cons:

  • We wish there were some healthier items since these are all sugary and salty

Spa Life All Natural Spa Gift Set

The spa he deserves

This luxurious gift set is a sure-fire hit for any man looking for some pampering.
Best For Men

Find on Amazon

We all deserve a little spa treatment from time to time. That’s why this spa gift set is perfect for that special someone in your life. This set is conveniently encased in a vinyl storage bag and includes all the items needed to pamper oneself. It includes a bubble bath, lotion, a body scrub, a sponge, and shower gel for relaxing during bathtime. The sandalwood scent is subtle yet attractive, giving this spa kit its “masculine” designation. That being said, anyone can enjoy the luxury of these items. After all, who doesn’t love the hearty aroma of sandalwood?

Pros:

  • The scent is great and not overpowering
  • The zippered basket stores everything neatly and has handles for transportation
  • A little of the lotion and gel goes a long way, so it can last quite a while

Cons:

  • The bag isn’t very durable or high-quality

Frequently Asked Questions

Will I know what’s in the mystery box?

Some of the mystery boxes on our list tell you exactly what items are included in the set, while others do not. Check the product listing or inquire with the manufacturer to determine if the item selection will truly be a mystery.

What types of mystery boxes are the best?

There is no clear answer to this. What do you love? There are mystery boxes for nearly anything. Toys, clothes, food, and more. Go with what you love.

Do mystery boxes make good gifts?

Mystery Boxes make great gifts. They include many products for the recipient to try, and because each box contains such a wide variety of items, there’s a good chance that they’ll love at least one of the items in the box.

About the Author

Hannah has always had an eye for fashion and beauty and is often inspired by the styles she sees on the streets of her beloved New York City. She closely follows the top fashion blogs and icons, and her goal is to help everyone look and feel their best through their clothing choices. Hannah’s work can be found in Boston Magazine, Hamptons Magazine, and more.

Why Trust Us

Since 2001, our experts at TheFashionSpot have been providing millions of people with our take on the latest trends. TheFashionSpot is constantly looking for the hottest styles in clothing and accessories for people of all body types. Our team knows that beauty starts well before the closet, so we are also dedicated to finding the best products for your skin and hair.