The Best Eyeliners
From sharp cat-eyes to dramatic designs, eyeliner can take your look to a whole new level. But the formula and style of liner are just as important as the technique you use. There are felt tips, liquid liner, and pencil eyeliner that each have their benefits depending on the look you're going for. Not to mention you'll need to choose between the different levels of pigment concentration, choose from waterproof options, and account for the sensitivity of your eyes should you need cleaner formulas to prevent irritation. As simple as one makeup item may sound, it can be overwhelming to decide which liner is right for you. To help you out, we've put together a list of some of the best eyeliners we could find.
NYX Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil
The whole package
This retractable eyeliner pencil by NYX is an all-around winner in our book. It offers a full-coverage application and a smooth, creamy formula that lasts all day — even through high heat and humidity. This eyeliner is waterproof, which means no smudging or bleeding once it’s dried, and it’s suitable for your waterline to create intense and detailed looks. We also love that this liner comes in 15 shades ranging from natural tones to fun, vibrant hues.
Pros:
- Cruelty-free
- Water-proof formula
- Great value for the price
Cons:
- This eyeliner is highly pigmented, so it can be easy to accidentally use more than needed
Covergirl LashBlast Mascara & Perfect Point Eyeliner
You can have it all
Complete your eye look with this kit of volumizing mascara and water-resistant eyeliner. The mascara is designed to give your lashes 10 times more volume without clumping, while the eyeliner features a smudging sponge for a dramatic effect. The liner is made of rich pigment and is self-sharpening, so there’s no need to fuss with a separate sharpener or stress over dull tips. With no flaking or tugging, enjoy perfect lashes and bold lines all at a price that can’t be beaten.
Pros:
- Self-sharpening applicator
- Rich, deep color
- Includes 1 mascara and 1 eyeliner
Cons:
- The mascara can be difficult to remove
Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner
Apply with precision
This quality liquid liner will be your new go-to for sharp, defined lines. It boasts an ultra-fine-tipped brush and a smudge-free, fragrance-free formula that’s made to last up to 12 hours. This liner will give you a continuous flow of highly pigmented color with just one go, so you’ll be able to achieve your look in a snap. Plus, we love that this pen was designed with a comfortable grip for non-slip, flawless application. Master the art of the cat-eye with this liquid eyeliner by Maybelline.
Pros:
- Precision felt tip
- Up to 12-hour wear
- Great for sensitive eyes
Cons:
- It might take a minute to dry completely
Spdoo Matte Liquid Eyeliner
Express yourself
Whether you’re in entertainment or you’re just a makeup mogul who loves to stand out, this collection of brilliant eyeliner colors is calling your name. You’ll receive 12 different colors of liquid liners that have a matte finish and a waterproof formula. This liner is water-infused and lightweight, so you’re free to choose between a subtle application or layer it on for dramatic color. The brush heads are also very fine and come to a sharp point should you need to create intricate designs.
Pros:
- Easy to remove
- Comes in 12 gorgeous colors
- Option for a shimmer eyeliner set
Cons:
- We wish it also came in black
iMethod Eyeliner Stamp
Perfect symmetry
Do you love the look of cat-eyes but still struggle to create precise wings? This eyeliner stamp by iMethod has you covered. You’ll receive two eyeliners — one for your right eye and one for your left — each of which features a stamp head on one end and a liner pen on the other. All you have to do is stamp the pigment where you would normally start your wing, then simply define it and fill your lash line with the pen. Water-proof and smudge-proof, this eyeliner stamp will help you get symmetrical wings every time.
Pros:
- Perfect for beginners
- Water-proof and smudge-proof formula
Cons:
- We wish the liner pen side was much finer
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between liquid and pencil eyeliner?
Liquid eyeliner sounds just like what it is: a liquid color. These are best for creating sharp points and precision lines, like cat-eyes. Pencil liners are similar to the texture of a crayon and are great for bold, smokey eyes or purposeful smudging. The downside to some pencil liners is that they require a sharpener of some sort. You could even do a combo of both kinds depending on the look you’re going for.
Should my eyeliner be water-proof?
It doesn’t have to be. Water-proof formulas will help to prevent smudging and bleeding even through rain, sweat, and tears. The downside is that they can be difficult to remove unless you have makeup-specific wipes. Liners without a water-proof formula can typically still hold their own depending on the activity you’re doing. Essentially, it all comes down to your specific needs and preferences.
How can I prevent my eyeliner from smudging?
There are a few ways to prevent your eyeliner from smudging, creasing, and running. First, using eyeliner with a waterproof formula will always help as they are designed not to smudge once dried. Secondly, make sure you’re priming your eyes just as you would your face before using foundation. You should always have a solid base wherever you’re applying makeup. And thirdly, you can set your eyeliner with a translucent powder or long-wearing eyeshadow that is the same color as your liner. You should also try not to blink too much or move your lid while your eyeliner is drying.
About the Author
Why Trust Us
Since 2001, our experts at TheFashionSpot have been providing millions of people with our take on the latest trends. TheFashionSpot is constantly looking for the hottest styles in clothing and accessories for people of all body types. Our team knows that beauty starts well before the closet, so we are also dedicated to finding the best products for your skin and hair.